Homes Burned, Not Eucalyptus
Link to KHMB Coastal Windage Discussion about Coast Eucalyptus Trees 3/28/25. Starts at 20:15
It seems that public agencies are finally acknowledging that trees are not always causing homes to burn in wildfires in the WUI:
New York Times: Many California Trees Survived Wildfires: LA FIRES (LA Times article March 21, 2025): “In reality, trees are fairly fire resistant, and many will likely recover, resprout and stick around for years. Even some non-native species that are known for being flammable, like eucalyptus trees, still linger.”
“The trees survived because they are filled with water: The roots draw moisture from soil and transport it through branches to its leaves. When the fires erupted in January, trees in Los Angeles had been especially nourished after two previous rainy winters. All that water makes burning a living tree akin to trying to start a campfire with wet logs, Dr. Jacobsen said.”
Our homes are more flammable than trees. They are made from dried out wood, petrol by-products such as paints and plastics. Keep in mind a tree is less flammable than your home as it contains a large percent of water. Our best defense is home hardening.
Paradise, California
The Camp fire burned homes but left trees standing. The science behind the fire’s path. LA Times Article, Nov 18, 2018
Fires that spread from house to house generate a force of their own. Embers, broadcast by the wind, find dry leaves, igniting one structure then another, and the cycle is perpetuated block after block. Break that cycle and the fire quits, and destruction can be minimized.
Most telling were the trees. Most of the pines that sheltered this community still had their canopies intact. The needles, yellowed from the intense heat, were not burned — evidence that the winds that morning had pushed the fire along so fast it never had a chance to rise into the trees. But as a surface fire, it lit up the homes that lay in its path.
Camp Fire in Paradise, CA (LA Times Article, Nov 18, 2018)
Why California Can’t Chainsaw Its Way Out Of A Raging Inferno (Buzz-Feed.News November 20, 2018)
Some of the news photos from the devastation in Paradise, California, show a surprising scene: Green, living trees stand near homes that have been reduced to ashes.
“Thin a forest too much and you reduce natural windbreaks that can help slow a fire’s spread, Dominick DellaSala of the Geos Institute in Ashland, Oregon, told BuzzFeed News. “You’re going to get a fire racing through.””
“When a fire overtakes a town like Paradise, what usually happens isn't that the trees ignite buildings, but rather that buildings that haven’t been hardened against fires ignite from a storm of embers that got ahead of the main fire front,” Cal Fire Deputy Chief Scott McLean told BuzzFeed News.
“In 2016, ecologists led by Curtis Bradley of the Center for Biological Diversity in Tucson, Arizona, looked at 1,500 fires over three decades that collectively burned across more than 35,000 square miles. They found that forests that had been selectively logged actually experienced more severe fires. The least severely burned forests, it turned out, were the most heavily protected where no logging took place — the very ones that were supposed to be most at risk.”
Scripps Ranch, San Diego, CA
At the time that it occurred, the 2003 Cedar Fire was the largest wildfire in California’s history.
Pushed along by Santa Ana winds, the Cedar Fire burned terrain at a phenomenal rate, making its way from Cleveland National Forest to Scripps Ranch.
An entire neighborhood of homes in San Diego burned in 2003, but the surrounding eucalyptus just a few feet away did not ignite.